TRM Packaging All articles
Operations & Efficiency

Beyond the Cheapest Bag: A 2026 Framework for Choosing Void Fill

TRM Packaging
Beyond the Cheapest Bag: A 2026 Framework for Choosing Void Fill

Photo: packaging void fill materials paper air pillows starch peanuts warehouse comparison, via content.bookoff.co.jp

Void fill is often bought the way stationery is bought: the same material is reordered until someone questions the price. That habit is understandable, but it hides a more useful question. Which material is doing the right job for the parcel in front of the packer? Paper, starch peanuts, air pillows and recycled plastic do not solve the same problem. A material that suits a light, non-fragile order can be a poor choice for a heavy or fragile one, and the cheapest bag of fill is rarely the lowest total cost per parcel.

This 2026 buyer's guide sets out a practical framework for UK SMEs shipping mixed product ranges. It compares the main options on protection, recyclability, storage footprint and per-parcel cost, and it avoids treating any material as universally greener than another.

Define the job before comparing materials

Void fill performs three distinct jobs. It can immobilise a product so it does not move; it can cushion against impact; and it can simply fill empty space so the outer box does not collapse. Some materials are good at all three; most are better at one or two.

Before comparing suppliers, classify the parcels that leave the warehouse. A useful split is: light and non-fragile, light and fragile, heavy and non-fragile, heavy and fragile. Also note box sizes. A material that works in a 30 cm box may be impractical in a 60 cm box because of the volume required. This classification prevents a single-material policy from being applied to a mixed range.

The four common options at a glance

The table below is a starting point, not a specification. Protection ratings depend on the product, the box and the packing method. Recyclability depends on the material stream and the local authority.

Material Best at Main limitation Storage footprint Typical cost pattern
Paper Void fill, light cushioning, presentation Weight and volume; can compact Moderate to high Moderate per parcel; higher labour if hand-torn
Starch peanuts Light fragile items, interlocking cushioning Moisture sensitivity; messy; high volume High before use Moderate; can be costly if overused
Air pillows Filling large voids, light protection Weak immobilisation; film recyclability Low before inflation; needs inflator Low material cost, equipment and labour matter
Recycled plastic film Cushioning, water resistance, heavy items Recyclability varies; storage volume Moderate Moderate; strong protection per gram

Paper: reliable for void fill and light protection

Paper is the default for many UK SMEs because it is widely accepted in household recycling, easy to store and simple to present. Crumpled paper, paper void fill systems and honeycomb paper all work best when the packer uses enough material to create a firm structure. Loose paper that merely fills a gap can settle in transit.

Paper is less efficient for heavy items and for products that need sustained cushioning. It also adds weight, which matters for carriers with weight-based pricing. The storage footprint can be significant if buying in bulk, although flat paper takes less space than pre-expanded alternatives. For mixed ranges, paper is often the best general-purpose fill and a poor choice for the heaviest or most fragile parcels.

Starch peanuts: useful for light fragile items, with caveats

Starch peanuts interlock well and are effective for light, fragile items where the product needs to be held away from the box walls. They are lightweight and can be composted in industrial conditions, but that does not make them suitable for every disposal route. In the UK, home composting claims should be checked carefully, and damp conditions can cause the material to soften or stick.

Storage is the practical drawback. Peanuts take up a large volume before use, and they can migrate around a packing bench. They are also poor for heavy items because they compress and shift. For a business with limited space, a small range of light fragile products and a clear disposal message, they can be a sensible option. For a high-volume mixed range, they are usually not the simplest choice.

Air pillows: efficient for large voids, weak on immobilisation

Air pillows are excellent at filling large empty spaces with low material weight. They reduce box collapse and provide light cushioning, and they take up little storage space before inflation. That combination can be attractive for businesses with limited warehouse space and a high proportion of light orders.

The limitations are equally clear. Air pillows do not immobilise a product well unless used generously, and they can puncture. The film is not typically collected in UK kerbside recycling, so the disposal route depends on store drop-off schemes or specialist collection. The per-parcel cost can look low on paper, but the inflator, film rolls, maintenance and packer time need to be included. For large, light parcels, they can be efficient; for heavy or fragile items, they are rarely sufficient alone.

Recycled plastic: protection where film is accepted

Recycled plastic void fill, including air cushions and loose fill made from recycled polymer, offers water resistance and good cushioning per gram. It can be useful for electronics, heavy items and parcels that may be exposed to damp. The recycled content is a genuine consideration, but it should not be confused with recyclability. The material still needs an accepted end-of-life route, and many UK households cannot place plastic film in kerbside recycling.

Where a business has a take-back scheme or a confirmed store drop-off route, recycled plastic can be a defensible choice. Where it does not, the material may reduce damage but complicate the disposal message. The buying decision should separate protection performance from disposal performance; both matter, but they are not the same claim.

Compare total cost per parcel, not per box of material

The cheapest material per cubic metre can be the most expensive per parcel if it takes longer to apply, requires more volume or leads to damage. A simple total cost calculation is:

Material cost per parcel + labour cost per parcel + storage cost per parcel + damage and return cost per parcel.

Labour is often the hidden variable. Paper that must be torn and crumpled by hand can slow a packing bench. Air pillows require inflation and a supply of film. Peanuts can slow packers because they need to be contained. A material that costs more per unit but saves ten seconds per parcel may be cheaper overall at volume.

Storage also has a cost. Peanuts and paper consume warehouse space; air pillows consume less before inflation but require equipment. For a UK SME with limited space, the storage footprint can be as important as the invoice price.

A simple decision framework for mixed ranges

Use four questions in order. First, is the product fragile or heavy? If yes, prioritise cushioning and immobilisation, and consider paper plus a cushioning layer, or recycled plastic where the disposal route is confirmed. Second, is the parcel mostly empty space? If yes, air pillows or paper void fill may be efficient. Third, what disposal route can the customer realistically use? Match the material to the local authority or take-back scheme, and avoid claims that cannot be supported. Fourth, what is the packer's time and storage constraint? A material that slows the bench or fills the warehouse is not cheap.

For mixed ranges, the answer is usually two or three materials, not one. A standard paper void fill for general orders, a cushioning format for fragile lines, and a large-void option for oversized boxes can cover most parcels without turning the packing bench into a materials library.

Trial before changing the specification

A two-week trial is enough to expose most problems. Record damage rates, pack time, material usage per parcel, storage space and customer disposal queries. Compare the trial against the current specification on total cost per parcel, not unit price. If the trial shows no improvement, the cheaper material may still be the right choice. If it shows a reduction in damage or labour, the higher unit cost may be justified.

The objective is not to find the greenest material in the abstract. It is to match the material to the parcel, the packing process and the disposal route the customer actually has. That is the practical route to lower total cost and fewer avoidable failures in 2026.

All Articles

Related Articles

When More Box Is Not Better: The Business Case Against Defensive Over-Packaging

When More Box Is Not Better: The Business Case Against Defensive Over-Packaging

The Second Journey: Designing Packaging for the UK's January Returns Window

The Second Journey: Designing Packaging for the UK's January Returns Window

Cutting Packaging Costs Without Cutting Corners: Seven Practical Changes for UK SMEs

Cutting Packaging Costs Without Cutting Corners: Seven Practical Changes for UK SMEs